Avg rating:
Your rating:
Total ratings: 2833
Length: 3:39
Plays (last 30 days): 2
I can't seem to say or do the right thing
Wanted to be sure you're feeling right
Wanted to be sure we want the same thing
She said, I can't believe it
You can't possibly mean it
Don't we all want the same thing?
Don't we?
Well who said anything about love?
No, not love, she said
Don't you know that it's different for girls?
Don't give me love
No, not love, she said
Don't you know that it's different for girls?
You're all the same
Mama always told me, save yourself
Take a little time and find the right girl
Then again, don't end up on the shelf
Logical advice gets you in a whirl
I know a lot of things that you don't
You wanna hear some?
She said, just give me something
Anything
Well, give me all you got, but not love
No, not love, she said
Don't you know that it's different for girls?
Don't give me love
No, not love, she said
Don't you know that it's different for girls?
You're all the same
You're all the same
You're all the same
You're all the same
You're all the same
You're all the same
You're all the same
You're all the same
Who said anything about love?
No, not love, she said
Don't you know that it's different for girls?
Don't give me love
No, not love, she said
Don't you know that it's different for girls?
Don't give me love
No, no, no, no, not love, she said
Don't you know that it's different for girls?
Don't give me love
No, no, no, no, no, not love, she said
Don't you know that it's different for girls?
You're all the same
You're all the same
You're all the same
You're all the same
You are correct. There's three versions of this song on that excellent live album: "regular", a capella and acoustic.
(A little late, but ...) this is incorrect - there are three versions of "Is She Really Going Out With Him?" on 1980-1986.
I remember being in 8th grade when this album came out
same!
Well, we agree about the pop masterpiece part anyways. Look Sharp (oddly, released in the same year!) was just as good, maybe better.
And real artists get kudos for not just replicating their winning formula and continue to grow and experiment. Beat Crazy had some really good stuff as did Night and Day.
After that, yea, I'd say the really good stuff was in the past.
Agree on Look Sharp, which was released at least stateside just a bit earlier. That one a Masterpiece as well. Two great Pop albums, then...........wad blown. Don't worry bout ole Joe though. I hear hes's a brilliant London Real Estate Investor
Don't know, could be a completely imagined event, as I had such a feeble grip on reality that week ...
You are correct. There's three versions of this song on that excellent live album: "regular", a capella and acoustic.
Posted 2 years ago by
ce:
nomnol wrote:
Joe also did a whole album without guitar. Can't remember which one but someone out there does. Bill maybe?
I think that's "Night and day" (with bass guitar), but you may be thinking of "Rain", which I'm not familiar with.
It seems he made at least TWO albums without guitar.
The Man likes a challenge. IIRC he recorded "Body and Soul" in a single recording for each song, and "Big World" live with a silent audience.
Thanks ce. That's the one. Just bass. I vaguely recall an interview where he said something to this effect. Wow.
I still love this song. To bad it doesn't segue into the Doors - Your Lost Little Girl anymore.
It just did.
Cmon I am trying to turn RP off and watch a movie! One great song after another after another after another. SHEESH!
I have been there so many times before. Its call ADDICTION and its the best one I've had.
He puts on a hell of a live show. super tight band. worth catching.
Cmon I am trying to turn RP off and watch a movie! One great song after another after another after another. SHEESH!
This happened the other day at the office...I put on my mid-fi Sennheiser cans to go loud on something good and still had them on four songs later...it was a good set!
I still love this song. To bad it doesn't segue into the Doors - Your Lost Little Girl anymore.
It did today.
I wish us all moments of love and happiness to savor <3
iirc the Bass on Jumpin' Jive was an upright (long time ago interveiw about why he made the album), or Maby made his electric sound like one for it, and there were no guitars on that album.
Had no idea it was that old. I remember listening to Joe on childhood camping holidays. Love this song.
I think that's "Night and day" (with bass guitar), but you may be thinking of "Rain", which I'm not familiar with.
It seems he made at least TWO albums without guitar.
The Man likes a challenge. IIRC he recorded "Body and Soul" in a single recording for each song, and "Big World" live with a silent audience.
phlattop wrote:
IIRC, there's a a cappella version on his Live 1980/86 album. Given how tight his band is live, it may match what you heard.
You are correct. There's three versions of this song on that excellent live album: "regular", a capella and acoustic.
I was in the 11th grade.
Junior in college...................
I was in the 11th grade.
Just did today 2019 March
Well, we agree about the pop masterpiece part anyways. Look Sharp (oddly, released in the same year!) was just as good, maybe better.
And real artists get kudos for not just replicating their winning formula and continue to grow and experiment. Beat Crazy had some really good stuff as did Night and Day.
After that, yea, I'd say the really good stuff was in the past.
This is only his second album. The ones that followed — Beat Crazy, Jump 'n' Jive, Night and Day, Big World, Laughter and Lust — are all excellent works.
aspicer wrote:
For sure...really a big missing on RP overall.
thewiseking wrote:
wow, who knew the bloke had such serious biz skills! A chain of burger restos, real estate holdings, ownership of a Football Club! Joe really is The Man
thewiseking wrote:
The "real" Elvis Costello like Orbison is the "real" Elvis
That's a nice comment, I need to think about it some more.
good call DaveInVA
The "real" Elvis Costello like Orbison is the "real" Elvis
Agree. He has a fairly large catalog and some stellar music.
For sure...really a big missing on RP overall.
sAwqTmawanaaIts exactly what I meant to say as they play The Cowboy Junkies after it that time and this time.
Now its back to the Doors after this...
WwAaa
Qawq
I think I'm missing something in the translation ...
sAwqTmawanaaIts exactly what I meant to say as they play The Cowboy Junkies after it that time and this time.
Now its back to the Doors after this...
WwAaa
Qawq
Like "Is she really going out with him" this track absolutely drips with teenage angst!
What a consummate musician he is...and has so many other great ones....I'll have to upload 'Sunday Papers' and more!
Ask and ye shall receive. Good get, Dave. Thanks for paying attention, Bill.
Then, to his credit I suppose, he started trying different styles and genres.
Aside from Steppin' Out, none of them worked as well as the first two, IMO.
Volume four? Mind you, he had the old band together for that.
Reminds me of:
For a girl to want sex, she has to be in the mood. For a guy to want sex, she just has to be in the room.
You mean it should drive a segway to another song??
Oh hang on, perhaps it was segue... (Yes, the spelling nazi has arrived!)
I don't know what you mean to say, but You're Lost Little Girl just followed up this song...
Its exactly what I meant to say as they play The Cowboy Junkies after it that time and this time.
Now its back to the Doors after this...
I don't know what you mean to say, but You're Lost Little Girl just followed up this song...
Then, to his credit I suppose, he started trying different styles and genres.
Aside from Steppin' Out, none of them worked as well as the first two, IMO.
joining JJ jam !
Sorta Steely Dan-meets-XTC.
Awe man! I'm back in Harford Hall, my senior year at Maryland, with the windows open on a nice sunny spring day with the speakers of my stereo singing out this perfect song.
Same ('62)
evermovingtarget wrote:
IMHO...
IIRC, there's a a cappella version on his Live 1980/86 album. Given how tight his band is live, it may match what you heard.
IMHO...
Always interested in if a male writer can grab the mindset of women I asked my girl if this rang true. She emphatically said yes.
I have actually had several frank conversations with women about this.
GONG
Always interested in if a male writer can grab the mindset of women I asked my girl if this rang true. She emphatically said yes.
Right toe.
Just played along and you are right!
ME TOO! Funny. And then the chorus has a Steely Dan feel to it.
Totally digging it.
I've seen him live three times. Every show was more brilliant than the last. This guy is truly talented. Too bad he's a vampire now.
there are a few versions on that album right? My fave is the acapella version.
That's right...What a shame !
So true. Very underrated!
That's right...What a shame !
jp
That would have been 1986's Big World, recorded live—and before an audience, you, that had to sit on its hands until the tape stopped rolling between songs. The critics really lambasted him for this, I guess for depriving the audience of its spontaneity. Frankly, I never understood that criticism. What I found remarkable was the boldness of the proposition: cut a live album and make it sound like a studio album. Every part had to be played perfectly. The fact that Big World was recorded over four nights is testament to how really, really hard that is to do. Man, do I envy you for having been there. Must have been something.
jp
How COOL! I'm currently fund-less, but I've put your rec on my new list of "must-buy" music. Thanks, jpwright!
jp
Yep: