Avg rating:
Your rating:
Total ratings: 3589
Length: 3:18
Plays (last 30 days): 2
I wish I was a sacrifice, but somehow still lived on
I wish I was a sentimental ornament you hung on
The Christmas tree, I wish I was the star that went on top
I wish I was the evidence, I wish I was the grounds
For 50 million hands upraised and open toward the sky
I wish I was a sailor with someone who waited for me
I wish I was as fortunate, as fortunate as me
I wish I was a messenger and all the news was good
I wish I was the full moon shining off your Camaro's hood
I wish I was an alien at home behind the sun
I wish I was the souvenir you kept your house key on
I wish I was the pedal brake that you depended on
I wish I was the verb 'to trust' and never let you down
I wish I was a radio song, the one that you turned up
I wish...
I wish...
This song has it all... incredible melody, production, restraint, AND THOSE LYRICS. Some of the best ever written.
"I wish I was a messenger and all the news was good."
Sublime
I kid.
c.
If we could all just take a deep breath, relax, and stop using apostrophes with plurals...
What is up with that? Drives me crazy.
Oh, and PSD PJ.
I agree!! That also happened today (12/12/20). I LOVED LOVED this segue!! It makes me realize that certain song combos are pre-programmed into RP's cycle of songs. Long live RP! Great work!
Today (January 2, 2022), the station played Wishlist, then "I Burn Today" by Frank Black, then PIN by Rheostatics. Still close by, but a different segue.
I agree!! That also happened today (12/12/20). I LOVED LOVED this segue!! It makes me realize that certain song combos are pre-programmed into RP's cycle of songs. Long live RP! Great work!
"I wish I was a messenger and all the news was good."
Sublime
heh? what are you hearing?
Hum, let's stop a second and read aloud... yes ok you are right.
Only if they never play a single track more from U2, Travis, Coldplay or Elbow. Deal?
Sounds like RP isn't for you. You should ask for your money back.
Only if they never play a single track more from U2, Travis, Coldplay or Elbow. Deal?
And Radiohead. And Arcade Fire. And Decembrists. Now, if you're a fan of any of those, would you still want the deal?
Nyah nyah ain't gonna happen, so I'll take PJ. Anyway, great band, and whether me or you, more or less PJ comes sooner or later with the downer sauce of RH and AF.
Only if they never play a single track more from U2, Travis, Coldplay or Elbow. Deal?
8 up to 9
Happy Holidays Dear Rockers
Happy Independence Day All : )
Steve wrote:
Agree.
Gabba gabba. One of us.
If I were you I would told him the truth.
My high school professor taught me this 35 yrs ago.
Oh sweet bird of youth.
and it's a done thing.
I wouldn't call that singing, Fred.
8 up to 9
Happy Holidays Dear Rockers
There is this new movie out on cable call “Pearl Jam twenty”. There is a scene of footage from a concert where the band has a George W. Bush mask perched high on a stick while they burn it and sing some creepy verses while they get resounding boos from the crowd. Vedder is unperturbed of course when asked why he did this. He is on an entirely different plane from ordinary people. He truly believes he is the messiah. I’ve never seen anything like it.
Long Island is a bastion of suburban Republican's and particular the white ethnic kind that got very understandably worked up by the attack of 9/11. By 2003 many American's, including PJ and including me realized that a) we attacked the wrong country (Iraq did not harbor Al Queda) 2) the Bush/Cheney administration had other reasons ($$$) for their war stance etc. Many other American's disagreed - as is their right as an American. Ed and the band expressed their free speech rights by playing the song. A large part of the crowd expressed their 1st amendment rights by booing and starting the USA chant. Ed, being a patriotic American, picked up on and continued the USA chant and summarizing it up -- talked about what a great example of free speech and American ideals that the "debate" over the song was.
It wasn't Ed thinking he was the messiah. Bruce doesn't think he is the messiah. Peter Gabriel doesn't think he's the messiah.Bono doesn't think ---- well he may think he is but it doesn't matter. Just because they choose to use their art to express their politics or values. They have just as much right to express themselves in free societies - like the US and most of Europe and other countries as anyone
In total agreement, lemmoth.
There is this new movie out on cable call “Pearl Jam twenty”. There is a scene of footage from a concert where the band has a George W. Bush mask perched high on a stick while they burn it and sing some creepy verses while they get resounding boos from the crowd. Vedder is unperturbed of course when asked why he did this. He is on an entirely different plane from ordinary people. He truly believes he is the messiah. I’ve never seen anything like it.
Long Island is a bastion of suburban Republican's and particular the white ethnic kind that got very understandably worked up by the attack of 9/11. By 2003 many American's, including PJ and including me realized that a) we attacked the wrong country (Iraq did not harbor Al Queda) 2) the Bush/Cheney administration had other reasons ($$$) for their war stance etc. Many other American's disagreed - as is their right as an American. Ed and the band expressed their free speech rights by playing the song. A large part of the crowd expressed their 1st amendment rights by booing and starting the USA chant. Ed, being a patriotic American, picked up on and continued the USA chant and summarizing it up -- talked about what a great example of free speech and American ideals that the "debate" over the song was.
It wasn't Ed thinking he was the messiah. Bruce doesn't think he is the messiah. Peter Gabriel doesn't think he's the messiah.Bono doesn't think ---- well he may think he is but it doesn't matter. Just because they choose to use their art to express their politics or values. They have just as much right to express themselves in free societies - like the US and most of Europe and other countries as anyone
Please add me as a member of the SPES. You are not alone! ;-)
There is this new movie out on cable call “Pearl Jam twenty”. There is a scene of footage from a concert where the band has a George W. Bush mask perched high on a stick while they burn it and sing some creepy verses while they get resounding boos from the crowd. Vedder is unperturbed of course when asked why he did this. He is on an entirely different plane from ordinary people. He truly believes he is the messiah. I’ve never seen anything like it.
... I do not like them, Sam I am.
Agreed, except not a big PJ fan.
That would be impressive if flipping burgers wasn't so frigging easy.
owned!
You cannot change the figures on my paycheck though and they do not match a frycooks. Owned.
Although I agree with you on the fact that one cannot say that something sucks or not, I do feel compelled to say the voting doesn't mean anything either. Especially if you take into account that renowned artists and bands such as Pearl Jam often get high scores no matter what song is on. I feel this song's rating is overly positive, but hey, who am I?
I think you summed up the great all-time debate about art. To wit, there is a certain objectivity about "good" art (i.e., reputation), and a certain subjectivity about "good" art (i.e., do you like it?). If we were all to adopt the orthodoxy of the former, more powerful and oppressive school, then we may as well all stop commenting henceforth and submit to the tyranny of the innumerable nitwit parrots who perfunctorily give high ratings to anything by reputable bands. I'll side with Sir Joseph on this one, for sticking to his guns, even though I like this song.
Paul_in_Australia wrote:
The ineluctable modality of the audible. I think the last paragraph of your comment deserves further analysis. It sounds like it is a quote from a character in a novel. "Brad drew on his first Marlboro of the day, and opined at length about the origins of the Universe. Being still intoxicated from last night's bourbon, he segued seamlessly to the origins of music, before getting confused, and ascribing the origins of the Universe to Chuck Berry, then Little Richard, and finally developing a Grand Theory of Relativity which embraced the 'Great Two' as originators of all matter in the Universe, as well as being progenitors of be-bop, rock and roll, new wave, but not hip hop and rap, which he denounced as the work of the devil, < or on retelling Eminem, assuming the two were actually different people> "
Can't believe I missed this. Paul — if your still out there — Bravo man. This is brilliant. LMAO
I think you are outvoted on if the song really sucks. Look at the average rating.
Just because YOU think it sucks, does not ACTUALLY mean that it sucks, fyi.
Although I agree with you on the fact that one cannot say that something sucks or not, I do feel compelled to say the voting doesn't mean anything either. Especially if you take into account that renowned artists and bands such as Pearl Jam often get high scores no matter what song is on. I feel this song's rating is overly positive, but hey, who am I?
Brilliant. -Huge favorite at the live shows.
That would be impressive if flipping burgers wasn't so frigging easy.
owned!
Were you a student there?
I think you are outvoted on if the song really sucks. Look at the average rating.
Just because YOU think it sucks, does not ACTUALLY mean that it sucks, fyi.
Duh. I think this song sucks. There, does that make you feel any better?
OH yes, no question. However if I got paid for writing songs as Pearl Jam does and I knew I sucked, I would feel at least a twinge of guilt for getting paid. So I may suck at it the same as Pearl Jam, but am guilt free since I am damn good at what I get paid for!
I think you are outvoted on if the song really sucks. Look at the average rating.
Just because YOU think it sucks, does not ACTUALLY mean that it sucks, fyi.
Were you a student there?
No, I do not like Pearl Jam.
Were you a student there?
LOL. I bet "you wish" you could write music, period.
About right?
OH yes, no question. However if I got paid for writing songs as Pearl Jam does and I knew I sucked, I would feel at least a twinge of guilt for getting paid. So I may suck at it the same as Pearl Jam, but am guilt free since I am damn good at what I get paid for!
A fantastic sing-a-long when seen live.
LOL. I bet "you wish" you could write music, period.
About right?
I wish I was the verb "to trust" and never let you down. Hm, how old would you have to be to come up with that? You'd have to at least be 13?
Go away.
No
Go away.
I'm not a huge fan either, but really, hyperbole much? Haven't you ever hear "We are the world"? or any boy band?
I actually like we are the world better! Seriously, I remember the first time I heard this song, I was like, really? This is not some kind of joke?
I'm not a huge fan either, but really, hyperbole much? Haven't you ever hear "We are the world"? or any boy band?
art.
Every time I hear this it always takes me back there.
For that - nothing short of 10.
Hey- this is actually a PJ song that I don't hate...
seamless, in fact.
The ineluctable modality of the audible. I think the last paragraph of your comment deserves further analysis. It sounds like it is a quote from a character in a novel. "Brad drew on his first Marlboro of the day, and opined at length about the origins of the Universe. Being still intoxicated from last night's bourbon, he segued seamlessly to the origins of music, before getting confused, and ascribing the origins of the Universe to Chuck Berry, then Little Richard, and finally developing a Grand Theory of Relativity which embraced the 'Great Two' as originators of all matter in the Universe, as well as being progenitors of be-bop, rock and roll, new wave, but not hip hop and rap, which he denounced as the work of the devil, < or on retelling Eminem, assuming the two were actually different people> "
? ?
The ineluctable modality of the audible. I think the last paragraph of your comment deserves further analysis. It sounds like it is a quote from a character in a novel. "Brad drew on his first Marlboro of the day, and opined at length about the origins of the Universe. Being still intoxicated from last night's bourbon, he segued seamlessly to the origins of music, before getting confused, and ascribing the origins of the Universe to Chuck Berry, then Little Richard, and finally developing a Grand Theory of Relativity which embraced the 'Great Two' as originators of all matter in the Universe, as well as being progenitors of be-bop, rock and roll, new wave, but not hip hop and rap, which he denounced as the work of the devil, < or on retelling Eminem, assuming the two were actually different people> "
While you're in MOPAR mode, don't forget the Charger. At one point I had all three, 2 '70's and a '69.
Help me - oh hippiecheck - to understand how you choose "heaven is a place where nothing ever happens" for a tag, and hate this song.
The T Heads tune is a mellow reflective tune similar to Wishlist. Both by great bands with great range, a great lead singer and a great live show.
I don't get it.
Sorry! Got to side with Hippiechick on this one! Admittedly I do not like Pearl Jam in general, never have although their first album is pretty good and they do have a few songs I like. Bottom line though, this song SUCKS!!!!!
Help me - oh hippiecheck - to understand how you choose "heaven is a place where nothing ever happens" for a tag, and hate this song.
The T Heads tune is a mellow reflective tune similar to Wishlist. Both by great bands with great range, a great lead singer and a great live show.
I don't get it.
That explains why it's about the only one I like a little.
7.
Yeah, me too. Although I wish Mike would lose that tinny-sounding Stratocaster and get a guitar with a good solid tone, like a Les Paul. But that's just the picky guitarist in me talking.
with all the gadgets out there now, there's any number of guitars you can emulate without getting a new guitar
Yeah, me too. Although I wish Mike would lose that tinny-sounding Stratocaster and get a guitar with a good solid tone, like a Les Paul. But that's just the picky guitarist in me talking.
Come to think of it, I wish I was the star that went on top of the Christmas tree, too...
Timmy Mack, Brooklyn, NY
I say the same thing every time I hear this: God I hate this song!
Oh, just go smoke a bowl and sit in your corner.
I say the same thing every time I hear this: God I hate this song!